Warning

Top 5 Everyday NYC Scams
Locals Should Avoid

Don’t get fooled! Learn how to spot and avoid these common scams in New York City.

Fake Taxis Street Hustles Overcharging
Author

Michael Rodriguez

NYC Local & Safety Expert

Published: August 15, 2025

New York City is amazing, but it’s also home to sophisticated scammers who target both tourists and locals. Even if you’ve lived here for years, new scams pop up regularly.

Why This Matters:

Every year, thousands of New Yorkers lose money to these scams. Some are harmless annoyances, while others can cost you hundreds of dollars.

Below are the 5 most common NYC scams you’re likely to encounter, along with how to avoid them.

NYC Guide

The 5 Most Common NYC Scams

Fake Taxi Scam
#1 Scam Times Square, Midtown

The Fake Taxi Scam

Unlicensed cabs charge outrageous fares or take "scenic routes" to inflate the meter. Some even use rigged credit card machines.

How It Works:

  • Driver claims the meter is "broken"
  • Extra "tourist fees" added

How to Avoid:

  • Only use yellow cabs or Uber/Lyft
  • Check for official TLC license
Three-Card Monte
#2 Scam Central Park, Broadway

Three-Card Monte

A street hustler challenges you to follow the "winning card" in a rigged game. You’ll always lose, and sometimes get pickpocketed.

How It Works:

  • Decoy players pretend to win
  • The game is impossible to win

How to Avoid:

  • Never stop to watch street games
  • Walk away if approached
Fake Charity Scam
#3 Scam Union Square, Subways

Fake Charity Donations

Scammers pose as volunteers collecting for fake causes, often using emotional stories to pressure you into donating.

How It Works:

  • Fake petitions or "donation sheets"
  • Aggressive tactics to guilt-trip you

How to Avoid:

  • Only donate to registered charities
  • Say "No" firmly and walk away
Overpriced Street Food
#4 Scam Times Square, High-Traffic Areas

Overpriced Street Food

Vendors charge $10+ for a single hot dog or pretzel, often without displaying prices until after you’ve taken a bite.

How It Works:

  • No visible price list
  • "Special tourist price" trick

How to Avoid:

  • Always ask for prices first
  • Walk away if prices seem too high
Fake Ticket Scam
#5 Scam Broadway, Sporting Events

Fake Ticket Sellers

Scalpers sell counterfeit tickets to shows, concerts, or sports events at inflated prices.

How It Works:

  • Fake or duplicated tickets
  • Last-minute "discounts" to pressure you

How to Avoid:

  • Only buy from official vendors
  • Check for holograms/security features

Final Safety Tip

Most scams rely on distraction. Stay alert, avoid engaging with street hustlers, and always verify prices before paying.

Stay Scam-Smart in NYC

Get weekly scam alerts and safety tips for New Yorkers.

No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.